Welcome back for another edition of A Second Look with Jeff Stockton! In this segment I will take a "second look" at a past LRF release with a fresh set of eyes.
When Season 7 GRA Best Picture winner The Squred Circle first debuted, I remember being blown away by how seriously it treated the world of professional wrestling—not as spectacle, but as generational burden. The film follows aging legend Wallace Dunbar (Mel Gibson), a hard-living icon clinging to one final match at WrestleFest, while his estranged son Ray (Tom Hardy), a former prodigy who fled the business, tries to maintain a quiet, sober life—until his own daughter Hannah (Anya Taylor-Joy) becomes drawn into wrestling herself. What unfolds is a multi-generational story about legacy, addiction, and identity, weaving together Wallace’s physical decline, Ray’s emotional scars, and Hannah’s curiosity about the family name. At the time, I compared it favorably to The Wrestler—not as bleak, but just as insightful in its own way. Gibson was electric, fully embracing Wallace’s volatility and regret, and the film felt like a definitive look at the cost of life inside the squared circle.
Taking A Second Look now, I still admire what the film is aiming for, but I’ve cooled on it slightly. Gibson remains the clear standout—a force of nature who gives the film its emotional backbone and volatility—but the rest of the cast doesn’t quite rise to meet him. Surprisingly, even Tom Hardy feels a bit muted here, and Kate Winslet still comes across as oddly misaligned with the tone of the story. The film is at its strongest when it’s examining the psychological and physical toll of wrestling—the generational damage, the addiction, the identity crisis—and those moments still hit hard. But once the story shifts into the in-ring spectacle, it loses some of that grounded weight, feeling more conventional and less distinct. In hindsight, The Squared Circle is an important early entry in what has become a strong run of wrestling films in LRF, but not quite the all-timer I once thought it was.
Original Grade: A-
New Grade: B+
















