Friday, June 26, 2026

Writer Commentary: The Hammer of Thor

 

The Hammer of Thor
Genre: Action/Fantasy/Superhero
Director: Roar Uthaug
Writer: Roy Horne
Based on Marvel Comics characters
Cast: Channing Tatum, Sam Riley, Phoebe Dynevor, Mark Hamill, Sophie Lowe, Danila Kozlovsky, Laurie Davidson, Denis Menochet, Sung Kang, Jeanne Tripplehorn, Caitriona Balfe, Ulrich Thomsen, Adam Nagaitis, Jóhannes Haukur Jóhannesson


Plot: Odin (Mark Hamill), the King of the godly realm of Asgard calls upon his sons Thor (Channing Tatum) the God of Thunder, Balder (Danila Kozlovsky) the God of Light and Loki (Sam Riley) the God of Mischief. Odin sits upon Hlidskjalf, the throne of the ruler of Asgard, and tells his sons that he has received word that an army of ogres have attacked Nidavellir, the realm of the dwarves. Thor questions why they should care about the dwarves. Balder then reminds his hot-headed brother that the dwarves hold a valuable place in the Ten Realms as the finest forgers and blacksmiths. Odin asks his sons to go and defeat the rock trolls to keep the dwarves as friends of Asgard. Loki asks why he is being sent as he is not a warrior like his brothers. Odin tells Loki that it is never too late to learn something from his older brothers. [1]

[1] Welcome to The Hammer of Thor - I'm the writer, Roy Horne. I purposely didn't give a ton of backstory right away. One thing I was very conscious of here was introducing all three brothers as efficiently as possible. Thor asks why they should help the dwarves because he's still arrogant and doesn't understand responsibility yet. Balder immediately sees the bigger picture because that's who Balder is. Then Loki questions why he's even there because he's already convinced he's the least valued son in the room. Those three reactions basically tell you everything you need to know about the characters before anybody picks up a sword.

The three Odinson brothers make their way toward Bifrost, the rainbow bridge that can transport them to other realms where they find Lady Sif (Sophie Lowe) and the Warriors Three - Fandral the Dashing (Laurie Davison), Volstagg the Valiant (Denis Menochet) and Hogun the Grim (Sung Kang) - waiting to accompany them to battle in Nidavellir. The group crosses over Bifrost and finds themselves in Nidavellir where they quickly find themselves in the midst of the rock troll attack. Balder tells everyone to cover their eyes for a moment and uses his powers to momentarily blind the rock trolls with a bright blinding light. Sif and the Warriors Three take the chance and attack the disoriented trolls with their weapons. Thor summons bolts of lightning from the heavens to strike down several trolls. Loki uses his gift of sorcery to make several trolls attack each other. They all make pretty quick work of the trolls. Their victory is celebrated by the dwarves, who invite the heroes into their kingdom for a feast. [2]

[2] This scene isn't about defeating trolls. It's about showing how everybody approaches conflict. Thor uses force. Balder uses leadership. Loki uses manipulation. The Warriors Three use experience. Sif uses discipline. Once you understand how each character fights, you understand who they are. I also didn't want to spend twenty minutes introducing everybody individually. The Warriors Three work best when they feel like old friends you've dropped into the middle of an adventure.

During the feast, the dwarves gift the sons of Odin each with a special weapon to show their appreciation. Thor is given Mjolnir, a mighty hammer that can harness the power of thunder. Balder is given Svraden, a majestic sword that can emit the brightness of a star. Loki is given the Laevateinn, a staff which can channel his natural sorcery into powerful energy blasts. Thor, Sif and the Warriors Three get drunk on dwarven mead. The calmer Balder goes outside away from the revelry to get some peace and quiet. [3] While drinking and partying, Thor and Sif steal away for a romantic encounter. Loki follows Balder outside and brings up a conversation about what should happen if their father, Odin, goes into Odinsleep anytime soon. Balder suggests that it is not their business what happens as their father will decide on a plan. Loki states that he believes Odin will select Balder or Thor to maintain the throne, but certainly not himself. Balder tries to reassure his younger brother, but Loki suddenly stabs Balder in the back with a poison dagger. Balder is stunned by Loki's actions and uses what little life he has left to question why Loki would choose to murder him. Loki explains that since Odin would never choose him to rule Asgard over Balder or Thor, he must take matters into his own hands to assure himself of the throne. Loki then runs back inside and frantically tells everyone that an assassin has murdered Balder. Thor runs outside to see Balder's body, trying in vain to bring life back to his brother. [4] Loki announces that he will head back to Asgard immediately to inform Odin and their mother. Thor grabs Mjolnir and proclaims that he will start searching for the assassin and beat him with his hammer. Thor, Sif, Volstagg, Hogun and Fandral all spread out around the dwarf kingdom in search of Balder's murderer.

[3] This whole sequence was designed around contrast. I wanted Balder to walk into the movie looking like the hero everybody expected Thor to be. Danila has this incredible movie-star presence. He's calm, handsome, noble, thoughtful. He looks like he stepped out of a fantasy painting. Channing's Thor, meanwhile, is getting drunk, chasing women, and generally not acting like a future king. That wasn't an accident.

[4] I think a lot of people had this image of Thor as the finished product. The noble king. The wise ruler. But if you read enough Thor comics, especially the early stuff, Thor spends a lot of time being arrogant, impulsive and emotionally driven. Taum was perfect for this starting point, which is ultimately what led to his casting over more obvious choices like Charlie Hunnam. I was casting the Thor at the beginning of it. Balder is the man Thor wishes he already was, and that's why losing him hurts so much.

Loki returns to Asgard, informing Odin and his mother Frigga (Jeanne Tripplehorn) that Balder has been murdered. Odin questions who could have been cunning or powerful enough to kill a fine warrior like Balder. Loki tells his parents that he suspects that Thor is the one responsible. Odin uses his powers to immediately summon Thor back to Asgard, demanding to know what happened to Balder. Thor regretfully confesses that he and his friends were celebrating and consuming libations following their victory over the rock trolls, so he was not witness to Balder's murder. Odin reveals that Loki suggested that Thor may have been the killer. Thor bristles at this revelation, insisting it isn't true. Odin states that while he does not believe that Thor was the murderer who physically wielded the knife that killed Balder, he still believes that Thor should have been there to help protect Balder. Loki enters that throne room. Thor angrily claims that Loki must be orchestrating all of this to claim the throne of Asgard for himself. Thor then attacks Loki, violently hitting him with Mjolnir. Loki is sent hurtling across the room into a pillar. Odin, in a rage, decides to banish Thor to Midgard and strips him of his godly powers, as well as his mighty hammer Mjolnir. Odin tells Thor that the way back home to Asgard will present itself once Thor has proven himself worthy of his godhood. [5]

[5] One of the things I was trying to do with Odin throughout these films is make him a very good king and a very flawed father. Those aren't the same skillset. Odin sees the larger problem with Thor immediately. Thor is reckless, impulsive, and wasn't where he needed to be when his brother died. Odin correctly identifies that. What Odin completely misses is the son standing right next to him... Loki.

Thor's body crashes down to Midgard, the Asgardian name for Earth, in a bolt of lightning. The year is 802 AD. When he finally wakes up, he finds himself in a clearing in a forest. As he wanders the forest, disoriented, Thor is confronted by a hunting party led by Anders (Adam Nagaitis) and Wulfgar (Jóhannes Haukur Jóhannesson). Without powers or any weapons, and still confused from being thrown into Midgard, Thor is overpowered by the two Viking warriors and captured in a large net. They drag him back to their village, Heorot. They bring Thor before King Hrothgar (Ulrich Thomsen), who demands to know what village Thor hails from. Thor claims he is Asgard and is a son of Odin. Hrothgar scoffs at this claim, stating that Odin is a god and all he sees before him is a foolish man. Hrothgar orders Wulfgar and Anders to chain Thor up outside until he decides what should be done with him. Hrothgar's daughter, Johanna (Phoebe Dynevor), watches. Her eyes catch Thor's eyes for a split moment. Thor is immediately taken with Johanna's beauty, boasting that he will make her love him, even if it is the last thing he does. When Anders sees how Thor and Johanna look at each other, he angrily tightens Thor's chains. [6]

[6] Setting the story during the Viking Age was easily the biggest swing I took in crafting the entire movie. Everybody knows Thor landing in modern America. Everybody knows Donald Blake. I wanted to know what happened if Thor landed among the people who would eventually tell stories about him. Instead of a superhero visiting Earth, it became a legend being born. The idea was that Thor wasn't arriving in the middle of his mythology—he was earning it. Most Thor adaptations start with the legend already existing. I wanted to tell the story of how the legend started. When I thought of the previous takes on the Marvel version of the character - MCU, NYC, etc. - I kept asking myself why we always rush Thor away from the people who actually believed in him as a God with a capital G. I also wanted the Vikings to react like real people. If some naked stranger fell out of the sky claiming to be the son of Odin, you'd probably chain him up too.

Loki secretly travels to another realm, Vanaheim. Deep in the dense forests of the realm, Loki rendezvous with his lover, Amora the Enchantress (Caitriona Balfe), who tells her that the dagger she gave him was successful in killing Balder. She asks what has become of Thor. Loki informs her that Odin stripped Thor of all his powers and gifts and banished him to Midgard until he is "worthy". Amora asks if Loki is worried about that. Loki laughs, insisting that everyone in Asgard knows Thor is a joke. Loki states that he will send a Fenris Wolf to kill Thor in his new realm, solidifying himself as the next ruler of Asgard once his father enters his Odinsleep. [7]

[7] This is probably the scene where I had to eat my vegetables as a writer. There's a lot of exposition here. We have to explain Loki's plan, establish that Amora was involved in Balder's murder, set up the Fenris Wolf, and make it clear what Loki thinks happens next. Normally I try to avoid spelling things out that directly, but I was also introducing Amora, who I'd wanted in the movie from the beginning. So the compromise became using the exposition to accomplish something else at the same time. If the audience is going to sit through a plot-explanation scene, they should at least get a new character and a new realm out of it.

Thor is still imprisoned in the courtyard of the village. Johanna brings him bread and water. Thor quickly eats it all up, thanking her. She asks why he claims to be the son of Odin. Thor says because it is the truth. Just then Wulfgar and Anders come running through the village toward the armory, clearly preparing for battle. Hrothgar demands to know what is going on. Anders informs him that a beast lurks in the woods beyond the village. Thor asks him to describe the beast. Anders struggles to describe, finally settling on it looking like a giant wolf with eyes as red as fire. Thor knows this is a Fenris Wolf and pleads with Hrothgar to free him to help fight it as he is familiar with the beast. Anders suggests that maybe Thor lured the beast here. Thor simply asks for a sword so he can help fight. Hrothgar orders Wulfgar to free Thor. To arm him, Anders gives Thor a dull sword. [8]

[8] This is the first scene where Thor starts earning people's respect instead of demanding it. Earlier in the film he keeps telling everyone he's the son of Odin, as if that should solve every problem. Nobody cares. What finally gets him taken seriously isn't his title—it's his knowledge. He recognizes the Fenris Wolf immediately. That's one of the reasons I liked setting the movie during the Viking Age. The villagers already believe in monsters and gods. They just don't believe this particular guy is one of them. Thor has to prove it. There aren't a lot of jokes in this film, I loved the idea that they free him, but Anders still gives Thor the worst sword he can find because Anders still thinks Thor is a fraud. It's not an "LOL" moment, but it made me chuckle as I wrote it.

Thor helps the warriors of the village track the Fenris Wolf into the deepest parts of the forest from its giant paw prints. The tracks eventually cease though, putting Thor and the vikings on high alert. The vikings decide to split up, even though Thor advises against it. Soon, Anders and Wulgar are cornered by the Fenris Wolf. Just as the wolf is about to crush Anders and Wulfgar with its giant canines, Thor leaps into action from a nearby tree and stabs the beast in the eye. Anders and Wulfgar are frozen in fright as they watch Thor grapple with the giant wolf. Thor hangs onto his sword which is protruding from the wolf's eye. He calls out to Anders and Wulfgar, asking them to give him one of their swords. Wulfgar tosses his sword up to Thor who uses it to stab the Fenris Wolf's other eye, blinding the creature. [9] Thor feels a slight burst of lightning power which he is able to use to stun the Fenris Wolf. The rest of the Vikings finally show up and begin firing arrows at the wolf with their bows. Thor grabs the swords from the wolf's eyes and uses them to stab it in the heart, killing it. [10]

[9] This might be the most "Viking" thing in the entire movie - and frankly probably pushed the studio's preferred PG-13 rating a bit. This version of Thor is not a master strategist like Balder or schemer like Loki - his solution to the monster problem is simple but effective: stab the giant wolf in the eyes.

[10] This is the scene the whole movie was built around. I always felt Thor needed to prove he was worthy before he got Mjolnir back, not after. He's got no armor, no hammer, almost no powers, and he's fighting a monster that everyone else is terrified of. If he only becomes a hero once the lightning returns, then the movie doesn't work. The lightning showing up is just the universe acknowledging what Thor has already become. I never wanted Thor's powers to come back all at once. I wanted them to return the way a muscle returns after an injury. If Thor can't be heroic without Mjolnir, then Mjolnir is the hero—not Thor. So this was the title character's real hero test.

Once they have discovered what has happened to Thor and that Loki claimed Thor killed Balder, Sif informs the Warriors Three that Thor could not have killed Balder that night since he was lying with her at the time. Volstagg wonders why Loki would make up such a thing. Fandral quietly suggests that Loki must know the real killer. Hogun grimly adds that Loki may be the killer himself. Sif suggests they keep this conversation between themselves as Odin may have banished Thor, but he would not hesitate to simply smite them from the ten realms. [11]

[11] This is the scene where the audience catches up to the movie. We already know Loki is guilty. Now the people closest to Thor are starting to figure it out too. I especially liked giving that progression to the Warriors Three. Volstagg asks the obvious question, Fandral starts connecting the dots, and Hogun immediately jumps to the worst possible conclusion—which of course happens to be the correct one. It's also one of the first scenes where Sif really emerges as the most perceptive person in Asgard. She's the only one with proof that Loki's story doesn't add up as she know what tawdry thing Thor was up to at the time instead. I felt like the Warriors Three really were underutilized in another company's Thor films, so making them active and important was one of my biggest goals with this story.

Loki tells Amora that he clearly underestimated Thor as he has managed to defeat the Fenris Wolf even without his powers. Amora asks Loki what should be next. He tells her that must go all-out now and summon Jormungand the World Serpent. Loki pulls out the dagger he killed Balder with, using drops of Balder's blood from it to begin the process. He drips the blood onto the head of a small snake. The snake begins to convulse and grow in size. Loki assures Amora that no amount of cunning and luck will be able to help a powerless Thor this time. [12]

[12] This is the point where Loki crosses a line even he can't really come back from. Earlier in the movie his goals are political—he wants the throne, he wants recognition, he wants control over his own future. Summoning Jormungand isn't political. It's madness. The Fenris Wolf failing forces Loki to confront something he doesn't want to believe: that Thor might actually be becoming worthy of the things Loki envies. So instead of adapting, he escalates. I also knew if I was making a Thor movie it might be my only chance, so there was no chance I was leaving Jormungand out of it. Thor and the World Serpent is one of the great rivalries in all of mythology.

 Thor and the Vikings return to Heorot with the severed head of the Fenris Wolf as a trophy. Anders and Wulfgar inform the village of Thor's bravery as he saved their lives from the beast. King Hrothgar thanks Thor, stating that he may not really be the son of Odin, but that doesn't mean he isn't a fine warrior and an honorable man after all. Hrothgar then proposes they celebrate and welcome Thor into the tribe. At the village's mead hall, Anders proposes a toast to Thor for saving his life, which Wulfgar seconds. While all the other vikings get drunk on mead, Thor sits down next to Johanna. She begins asking him more questions about Odin and Asgard. They spend all night talking to the point where they are the only ones still awake as all of the Vikings have passed out from over-consumption of mead. Johanna and Thor go outside and watch the sun rise. Thor admits that he has never seen a sunrise from Midgard before, but it might just be the second most beautiful thing he's ever seen. She asks what the first is. Instead of answering, Thor passionately kisses Johanna. [13]

[13] This is the scene where Thor finally stops trying to get back to Asgard. Earlier in the movie he's constantly talking about who he was—the son of Odin, the God of Thunder, the prince of Asgard. Here he's just Thor. That's one of the reasons I liked setting the story during the Viking Age. These two characters can literally spend an entire night sitting in a mead hall talking about the stars, the gods, and their lives. Hrothgar's acceptance is important too. He doesn't decide Thor is a god. He decides Thor is an honorable man. For me, that's actually a much bigger step in Thor's journey than him returning straight to godhood.

Odin informs Frigga that it will soon be time for him to enter his Odinsleep and asks her if she thinks that Loki can rule Asgard for a short while. Frigga confesses that she thinks Loki is a bitter, angry young man, but he is an Odinson so he will probably figure it out in the end. Odin confesses that he has become worried that whoever killed Balder may look to kill Thor now that he is powerless. Frigga hopes that Thor will prove himself worthy and his powers will find him again, but Odin says that he isn't holding his breath. [14]

[14] This scene became much more important after the sequel. At the time it looks like a simple conversation about succession, but it's really about parenting. Odin keeps evaluating his sons the way a king would—who can rule, who can protect the realm, who can handle responsibility. Frigga is the only person looking at them as people. She recognizes that Loki isn't really a political problem, he's an emotional one. One of the recurring themes I go back to multiple times in these Thor films is that Odin is a great ruler, but not a particularly good father. Even here, he's worrying about who can sit on the throne while completely missing what's happening inside his family.

Sif and the Warriors Three witness Loki sneaking onto the rainbow bridge in the dead of night. They decide to follow him as he traverses into the realm of Vanaheim. They sneakily follow him through the forest and to Amora's lair where they see the growing Jormungand, which is now nearly 100 feet long. Hogun believes it to be the start of Ragnarok. Fandral doesn't follow, so Hogun reminds him of the legendary stories that said that the death of Odin's favorite son will lead to Ragnarok - the cataclysmic destruction of all the realms that starts with a giant serpent. [15] Sif and the Warriors Three hurry back to Asgard to inform Odin, who finds their claims dubious at best. Frigga pleads with Odin to help Thor out in some way just in case what they are saying is true. Odin relents and says that he will send Thor's hammer Mjolnir to Midgard for him to find. [16]

[15] Up until now the characters have been dealing with murders, monsters, and political intrigue. Suddenly Hogun recognizes the signs of Ragnarok and everything gets much bigger. One thing I liked was tying Balder's death directly into that prophecy. In Norse mythology, Balder's death is one of the major warning signs that the end is coming, and I wanted that event to have real weight.

[16] This is a major shift in the story - bringing more of the myths to Earth. It's also a deeper dive into the relationship between Odin and Frigga - the most powerful royal couple in all of Marvel Comics. One thing I wanted to hint at here as well  is that Mjolnir isn't just a weapon for Thor - it's his destiny.

While Thor and Johanna are still enjoying the sunrise, they see something fall from the sky and strike a nearby mountain. Thor tells Johanna that he knows somehow that he needs to head to that mountain as soon as possible. Anders and Wulfgar stumble out of the mead hall and insist on tagging along with Thor on his trip to the mountain. They head there on horseback and find the hammer of Thor, Mjolnir. Thor tries to lift the hammer, but it doesn't budge from the rock of the mountain. Anders and Wulfgar each try as well, but can't even lift it an inch off the ground. Thor realizes that he hasn't quite deemed himself worthy to wield it yet. [17]

[17] Everybody knows what's supposed to happen here. Thor finds the hammer, picks it up, lightning starts flying, crowd goes wild. The whole reason I wrote the scene was so that wouldn't happen. He hasn't quite earned it just yet. The entire purpose of this scene is to deny the audience the payoff they're expecting. Everybody knows Thor is eventually getting Mjolnir back. The question is when. I always felt that if Thor became worthy the moment he defeated the Fenris Wolf, the story would be over too early. He's made tremendous progress, but he still has things to learn. I also liked that Thor doesn't throw a tantrum here. The Thor from the beginning of the movie would've blamed Odin or tried to force the hammer out of the stone. Instead he immediately understands why it won't move. That's probably the strongest sign yet that he's changing. It's all part of his hero's journey.

Loki and Amora open up a portal from Vanaheim to Midgard. Jormungandr slithers through the portal, now a massive serpent thousands of feet long. The portal opens up on a lake near Heorot and Jormungandr emerges from the lake, towering over the village. The creature is so massive that Thor, Anders and Wulgar can see the creature from the mountain. They hurry back to Heorot to find that the serpent has already started to destroy everything in the village with its fiery breath. Johanna leads all the women and children to the mead hall for safety, while all the men of the village grab their weapons - even King Hrothgar. When Thor makes it back, he immediately rides straight for the serpent and throws his sword at the beast. Thor is suddenly struck by lightning, re-granting him all of his god abilities. Mjolnir shakes free from the rock of the mountain and propels itself straight into Thor's hand. [18]

[18] This is really the payoff to the entire movie. The important thing isn't that Thor gets Mjolnir back. The important thing is that he's stopped caring about getting Mjolnir back. Earlier in the story he wanted the hammer because it represented his power, his status, and his old life. Here he rides straight at Jormungandr with nothing but a sword because there are people in danger. That's why the lightning returns. That's why the hammer comes to him.

King Hrothgar leads the vikings into battle, charging at the giant serpent. Jormungandr roars, causing an earthquake. The shaking earth causes a building to collapse onto Hrothgar, crushing him. He pleads with Thor, not to save him, but to save his people from this evil. [19] Thor promises and summons a bolt of lightning to strike the serpent. Seeing that Thor has had his powers restored, Loki comes through the portal to Midgard. Loki has Jormungandr set fire to the mead hall after blocking the doors, killing everyone inside - including Johanna. Anders and Wulfgar also die trying to rescue them. Thor cries in anger and flies at Jormungandr, hitting the serpent with thunderous blows from Mjolnir. Jormungandr bites Thor, poisoning him. Thor uses a stream of lightning bolts to charge his powers, before grabbing Jormungandr by the head and snaps its neck. [20] Jormungandr collapses before shrinking back down to its original size, revealing a small dead snake. Thor then turns to Loki, telling him that he is next in line to feel his wrath. Loki warns Thor that Jormungandr’s poison will kill Thor in nine steps. Thor doesn’t believe Loki, but Loki informs him that it is the same type of poison he used to kill Balder - the only poison strong enough to kill a god. Thor takes eight steps toward Loki. Loki smiles, just out of Thor’s reach. Thor uses his last step to strike Loki with Mjolnir, before succumbing to the poison. [21]

[19] I've long been a fan of Ulrich Thomsen, so I wanted to give him a really good moment even if the role isn't a major one for the overall Marvel Universe. It was important to me that Hrothgar never really cared whether Thor was the son of Odin - he simply cared whether Thor was honorable.

[20] Disney's MCU has had eight major appearances of Thor now but never bothered to include or mention the freaking MIDGARD SERPENT aka the WORLD SERPENT aka Jormungand. Always on the bench.

[21] "Before I had a finished outline, before I knew who Johanna was, before I knew how Thor would get banished, I knew there was one scene I wanted in the movie. If Thor fought Jormungandr, I wanted the nine steps. Once I decided Jormungandr was the villain, I knew I wanted to honor one of the most famous moments in all of Norse mythology. The trick was finding a way to do it without ending Thor's story completely. That's why Loki is standing at the end of those steps. In the myths, Thor's final act is killing the serpent. In our version, Thor's final act is reaching his brother. I admittedly had to remind myself a few times that this is the Marvel Universe - not a dark Norse myth - at its core.

Odin, Sif and the Warriors Three arrive in Midgard amongst the destroyed village. Odin uses his powers to revive Thor, killing the poison in his veins. Thor pleads with his father to save all the dead of Heorot. Odin says that is something he cannot do as he is not allowed to use his powers to affect Midgard. Odin then apologizes to Thor for not believing him about Loki. Odin adds that Thor has earned his powers and that Balder would be proud of him. Odin brings the injured Loki back to Asgard and imprisons him in the Yggdrasill, an empty void that binds all of the realms together. The Warriors Three begin helping Thor clean up Heorot while Sif helps bandage the injured people of Heorot. The people begin bowing down before Thor, proclaiming him as their new king. Thor, however, is unsure if he wants the responsibility. [22]

[22] The end of this scene is really the entire payoff to Thor's arc through the film. At the beginning of the movie he thinks he's ready to rule Asgard. He never even questions it. In his mind, kingship is just the next reward waiting for him. Then Balder dies, Hrothgar dies, Johanna dies, and Thor spends the entire film learning what leadership actually means. So when the people of Heorot start calling him king, he doesn't feel triumphant. He feels uncertain. Ironically, that's probably the first moment in the movie where he's actually worthy of being one. 

Back in Asgard, an official funeral is held for Balder. Thor is depressed at the loss of Johanna as he had never been in love before. Frigga informs her son that it may take hundreds or even thousands of years, but his love would one day return to Midgard. Thor asks for a more exact time frame. Frigga displays a vision of a woman who looks identical to Johanna in the 21st century working as a nurse. A surgeon calls her Ms. Foster. This makes Thor smile slightly. He tells his mother that he would like to wait in Midgard for Johanna’s eventual return. [23]

[23] This is probably the most obvious sequel setup in the entire film, and honestly that was intentional. The Johanna storyline was always designed to lead into Jane Foster eventually. The challenge wasn't setting up the sequel—it was making Johanna matter enough that audiences understood why Thor would choose to wait for her to be reborn. I never wanted Johanna to feel like a placeholder. She needed to feel like the great love of Thor's life. The vision of Jane isn't there to replace her. It's there to tell Thor that the story isn't over yet.

Well, that's all I've got. Thanks for joining me and taking another trip through The Hammer of Thor. I appreciate you spending your time with me, and who knows—maybe we'll have another story to talk about soon. Thanks for listening.


Thursday, June 25, 2026

Release: Echoes of Red

 

Echoes of Red
Genre: Thriller / Crime
Director: Emerald Fennell
Writer: Mo Buck
Cast: Cate Blanchett, Jeffrey Wright, Luke Evans, Jessica Barden, Vanessa Kirby, Robin Wright, Mark Strong, Ben Whishaw

Budget: $42,000,000
Domestic Box Office: $50,719,934
Foreign Box Office: $32,094,203
Total Profit: $10,590,000

Reaction: Mo Buck's first film since Season 30 didn't set the box office on fire, but it did score a little profit at least.



"A slick, psychologically rich thriller that leans heavily on mood and fractured memory, Echoes of Red thrives on its atmosphere and a commanding lead turn from Cate Blanchett, but occasionally loses clarity in its deliberately disorienting structure. The nonlinear storytelling and unreliable perspective are compelling at first, though the film risks repetition as it circles the same beats without always deepening them. Emerald Fennell’s direction keeps tension simmering, but the payoff feels slightly muted compared to the buildup. Still, it’s a stylish, performance-driven mystery that lingers even when it frustrates." - Brenton Smalls, Playboy


"Echoes of Red is a hypnotic, slow-burning thriller that thrives on atmosphere and psychological unease. Emerald Fennell leans into fractured memory and unreliable perspective, crafting a narrative that feels as disoriented as its protagonist. Cate Blanchett is, unsurprisingly, exceptional—balancing control, vulnerability, and quiet dread with precision. The film’s structure demands patience, but its layered reveal and haunting tone make it a rewarding experience." - Elena Sorrento, Velvet Frame



"While Echoes of Red has a compelling central idea, its execution can feel overly convoluted and self-indulgent. The fragmented timeline and repeated memory lapses, while intentional, become repetitive rather than illuminating, slowing the narrative to a crawl. Blanchett carries the film, but several supporting characters feel underutilized, and the mystery loses some of its impact by the time the pieces come together. It’s intriguing, but uneven." - Clint Avery, Backlot Review





Rated R for language, some violence, and thematic content.






Top 10 Cate Blanchett Films

 

Sherman J. Pearson here for another Top 10. Echoes of Red makes film number 11 for star Cate Blanchett, so I figured I might as well look at and rank the previous 10 films on her resume....

Top 10 Cate Blanchett Films
10. Hope, Sadness and Anger
9. The Water Cure
8. Made in Abyss
7. Mass Effect: Cerberus
6. The Queen of the Night
5. For Those Who Don't Read Me
4. The Betrothed
3. An Honest Mistake
2. Guilt
1. Mass Effect 3 - Part 2

Wednesday, June 24, 2026

Now Showing: Echoes of Red

 

Echoes of Red
Genre: Thriller / Crime
Director: Emerald Fennell
Writer: Mo Buck
Cast: Cate Blanchett, Jeffrey Wright, Luke Evans, Jessica Barden, Vanessa Kirby, Robin Wright, Mark Strong, Ben Whishaw

Plot: Monday, 8:12 AM

A gated manor sits on top of a hill. A splendid garden, tended by silent employees under the bright Monday sun. Surely the owners of the mansion lead a peaceful, idyllic life, right? The gardeners work in silence, save for the hum of sprinklers and the distant crackle of police radios. Evelyn’s (Cate Blanchett) heels click like a metronome as she descends the steps, a woman keeping time even as her world unravels. She exits through the front door, big sunglasses on her face, pristinely dressed as always. She towers over the police officer following her, Det. Nora Pierce (Jessica Barden). The gardeners follow with their eyes as the squad car carrying their boss exits through the gates. Inside the squad car, Det. Pierce allows Evelyn to contact her lawyer, which she accepts, but not without saying that she’ll live to regret this, it is all a mistake.

As they arrive at the station, Ms. Moreau is taken into interrogation by Pierce. She is joined by her partner and now lead investigator, Lt. James Royce (Jeffrey Wright). Royce tells Ms. Moreau they’ll wait for her counsel to arrive before starting. Evelyn assures them they won’t learn anything she hasn’t already told Pierce, whose diligent notes she has kept in mind. They’re interrupted by Catherine Voss (Robin Wright), Evelyn’s sorority sister, long-time friend and legal counsel. She immediately embraces Evelyn and says she’s sorry for her loss and asks her how she’s holding up. Evelyn says she’s still in shock and can’t believe she has to go through this. Voss analyzes the two detectives and asks if they realize who her client truly is — and warns they’ll regret treating her like a common criminal. Royce calmly reminds her that he’ll be the judge of that. They just want to shed light on the moments before Evelyn’s husband was found dead in the early hours of Monday morning. Royce’s phone buzzes on the table. He glances at the name : Chief Commissioner Delorme. He silences it. Catherine notices, and so does Evelyn.

Hours earlier - Monday, 3:25 AM

Evelyn panics as she sees her husband, Patrick (Luke Evans), collapsed on the floor - blood spreading across the beige carpet like a dark halo. For a second, she’s certain he blinks. Then he doesn’t. She frantically grabs the nearest phone, or maybe she already had it in her hand; she can’t remember. She dials 911, telling the operator she thinks her husband is dead. She starts to cry as she hangs up.

Hours earlier – Sunday, 10:45 PM

Evelyn dines with her husband at the long oak table, enjoying a quiet evening for once. They discuss plans for an upcoming charity gala, promising themselves not to repeat last year’s mistakes. Patrick jokes that the hors d’oeuvres were “criminally bad,” he’ll have a word with the charity coordinator, Vivienne, about that. It draws a laugh from Evelyn — though something in her tone feels off, a half-beat too flat. She notices a shadow moving in the hallway but dismisses it as the wind shifting a curtain. Her phone buzzes, from Catherine. Evelyn had texted her earlier to confirm their Monday morning meeting. The reply startles her: Everything will be fine, for now. Evelyn rereads the message several times, and each read subtly changes its meaning — reassurance, warning, threat. She can’t tell which anymore.

Immediately before the discovery – Monday, 3:05 AM

Evelyn wakes to a faint sound — a floorboard creaking, or maybe the clock ticking louder than usual. She glances at the bedside clock: 3:05 AM. The house feels colder than it should. Patrick’s side of the bed is empty. She slips into her robe and walks down the hallway. A few lights are on. On the desk, she notices two Post-it notes covered in her handwriting, but she doesn’t remember writing them. The words blur when she tries to read them.Patrick’s coat hangs over a chair. She’s sure she saw him in the study earlier — or did she only dream that? She calls his name. No answer. She retraces her steps. The rooms look slightly different than she remembers — as if the house itself is rearranging while she moves through it. She pins the discordance on her sleepiness, it’s the middle of the night after all.

Monday, 9:45 AM

Lt. Royce asks Evelyn to recount the events leading up to the discovery of her husband’s body. She’s pale, but composed. In a slow, deliberate rhythm, she reconstructs her version of the night. She sayd she woke up at 3:30 AM after hearing a loud thud from the study. She claims she called 911 immediately, around 3:31 or 3:32, she can’t quite remember. Nora quietly points out in her notebook that the call was lodged at 3:37. Evelyn continues, she found Patrick lying on the study carpet, she thinks he fell and hit his head. Royce corrects her, Patrick’s body was found in the bedroom, not the study. Catherine interjects, reminding them Evelyn is in shock, that she just lost her husband of ten years. Evelyn nods, a flicker of irritation crossing her eyes, but her attention drifts to the wall clock. It ticks loudly. She glances at her watch, it’s off by a few minutes, maybe, but she says nothing. Luke Morgan (Ben Whishaw), the forensics expert enters the room and gives Royce a folder. He tells Royce the blood pattern analysis is done, and doesn’t line up with a fall. Evelyn tilts her head and asks what fall they’re talking about. Royce says she just told them she believes Patrick fell and hit his head.

Later that morning

Evelyn sits alone in the interrogation room. The mirror reflects her oddly, her expression lagging a half-second behind. She thinks she sees movement behind her, but there’s nothing there. Her gaze keeps returning to the clock. It’s wrong. Or her watch is. She can’t tell anymore, and the uncertainty gnaws at her. Royce and Pierce re-enter, carrying photographs: one of the crime scene, Patrick’s body unmistakably in the bedroom; another showing Evelyn’s hands, faint traces of blood along the creases. She shakes her head. She doesn’t remember any of it. Luke, the forensic expert, steps in behind them, quietly placing a small evidence folder on the table. Preliminary analysis; traces of another person’s blood on the carpet and under the fingernails. Evelyn freezes. She shakes her head again. I don’t remember any of that she stutters. Royce asks her about Catherine, confirming Evelyn received a text from her after dinner. Evelyn insists she did. Royce slides a printout across the table, a screenshot from her phone; the timestamp: 11:58 PM. A beat of panic flashes across Evelyn’s face, but she forces composure. Across the table, Catherine observes Det. Royce, he noticed that flicker too. The detective, calm and almost gentle, might be better at his job that she expected. Royce’s phone vibrates again. He steps outside. Commissioner Delorme (Mark Strong) is on the other line, he tells Royce to stop bothering the Moreau’s. Their foundation financed the new hospital wing, he needs to stop crucifying the poor widow over a domestic tragedy. Royce tells him he suspects it’s not just domestic and Delorme orders him to make it look like it is. Luke lingers near the doorway, glancing back at Evelyn. His eyes are quiet but not neutral — he knows there’s more beneath the surface, even if he can’t yet say it aloud. Evelyn looks up, meeting his gaze for a fraction of a second, and the shadow of guilt she doesn’t fully understand flickers across her face.



Midday

Evelyn is left with Catherine in the interrogation room. The ticking clock seems inconsistent. She tries to concentrate and retells her version of events to Catherine. She remains convinced Patrick was in the study. She recalls a little blood, not the pool shown in the photographs. She begins to question herself, was there really blood ? Was it in the bedroom or the study. She called 911, but when was it ? It is killing her she doesn’t remember exactly. She can’t remember, the details are hazy. Catherine reassures her friend, saying everything will be fine, just like she texted her. She recalls going to see Vivienne (Vanessa Kirby) hours earlier, there was tension, Vivienne wasn’t happy and Patrick was mentioned, she doesn’t remember why. She remembers dinner with Patrick, they ate veal, or was it chicken, she can’t remember either. Pictures were out of place. Someone else had been in the house ? She notices a chipped wine glass. A faint stain on the carpet. Blood ? Or just wine? She doesn’t know for sure. She remembers hearing a laugh, whose was it ? Patrick’s ? Vivienne’s ? She remembers drinking wine. White ? Red? Or was it a rosée ? Catherine puts her hand on Evelyn’s shoulder, urging her to remain calm. Evelyn glances in the mirror, a flicker of guilt on her own face. She whispers to herself, did I ? No… I don’t remember. Catherine whispers that everything will be fine.

Afternoon

Royce and Pierce walk back in with new photographs, Pierce still carrying her notebook. They ask Evelyn to walk them through her memories of Sunday evening again. Catherine says they already did, pointing out the notebook, but Royce wants to do it again to clarify some things. She reminds them about the out of place picture frames, the shadow she thinks she saw, the chipped wine glass, the stain on the carpet, the little bit of blood she saw near Patrick. Royce points out the inconsistencies. Her fingerprints were found on the picture frames and no one else’s. There was no chipped wine glass anywhere in the house. He lifts a photo. You said there was just a little blood here, he says. He taps on the image; that’s a pool, Evelyn he adds. Evelyn denies the accusation Royce is implying and so does Catherine. Pierce breaks from her silence and brings up Vivienne. She notices an uneasy look from Evelyn as she mentions Vivienne. Evelyn recalls meeting with Vivienne earlier that day, there was tension but she couldn’t remember what it was about. Royce asked Pierce if she tried to contact Ms. Vivienne and Pierce says they couldn’t reach her. Evelyn keeps glancing at the clock, again, ticking seems off. She remembers handling the picture frames but doesn’t know why. Catherine tries to soothe Evelyn, saying everything will be fine. Royce receives another call from Delorme, which leaves Pierce alone with Evelyn and Catherine. Catherine smiles and asks Pierce what she writes in that big notebook of hers and she says she’s just keeping track of everything to make sure they don’t miss anything important. Catherine’s brow furrows as she glimpses the notebook. Pierce is only observing Evelyn, nothing more. Catherine wonders if every move her friend makes is being recorded. Pierce catches Catherine looking at her notes and closes it. She leaves the room to meet Royce. Evelyn collapses in her chair. Did I ? She stutters as Catherine tries to sooth her.

Afternoon

When Royce and Pierce come back with new photographs Catherine threatens to call Commissioner Delorme and end this circus. Royce only smiles: Delorme already knows. She wonders aloud if that’s why he keeps calling him. Royce shrugs — Delorme likes to be involved. Royce asks her when’s the last time Evelyn met with Vivienne. Evelyn is uneasy, which is diligently noted by Pierce. The ticking pulls her somewhere else — not the station’s clock this time, but another one, louder, echoing through marble walls.

The Evening of an earlier day

Evelyn is annoyed at the clock ticking in the lobby, it’s so loud, it breaks the dreadful silence of the lobby. She imagines Patrick and Vivienne, sleeping together in her own bed. She wonders if he also thinks the elevator is really slow in that building as she longed for Vivienne and couldn’t wait to get his hands down her blouse. Patrick was asleep at home, he has always been a night owl. She grabbed his phone and found out about his affair with Vivienne, their charity coordinator. She had texted Vivienne, or Viv as he called her to meet tonight, but little did she know that Evelyn would show up, and not Patrick. She gets on the elevator as she wonders how long the affair has been going on. Vivienne has been working at the foundation for five years now. Is it a new thing or has it been going on since she came in their lives ? Evelyn is mad at herself she didn’t notice it earlier, she could see it in his eyes. She’s at her door and knocks, her hand trembling. Vivienne opens the door in a white dress, calm, curious. The words blur in Evelyn’s head — a scream, laughter, a glass shattering, the sharp pop of a frame hitting the floor. A splash of red — wine, or not wine. Her hands gripping something. Silence. Then her own voice: “Don’t look at me like that.”

Afternoon

The ticking slows. The room reforms — Catherine’s hand on her arm, the sterile hum of the lights. Evelyn whispers, I fired her. Catherine shushes her, but Evelyn’s gaze fixes on the mirror. The frames… they weren’t there before,” she murmurs. Royce and Pierce exchange a glance, they sense something, but they can’t name it.

Sunday, or Saturday, Can’t remember

The manor feels too quiet, cold. Evelyn walks down the hall, her hair slightly disheveled, her face pale. She’s holding a towel, or a napkin with a faint reddish stain. She pauses, confused, wine perhaps ? She smells it, it’s clean. She drops it in the chute, uneasy. The ticking clock from earlier returns, faint in the background. On the console table, a picture frame is slightly crooked. She corrects it without thinking about it. Evelyn enters the dining room and she opens the curtains. There are two glasses on the table, one chipped, one isn’t. There are plates on the table, they still have crumbs in them. They did she give a day off to the cleaning lady ? She can’t remember. Did they have dinner here or somewhere else ? Evelyn blinks away, the sound of a glass shattering echoes faintly.

Patrick enters the dining room, asking his wife if she’s okay, she’s been quiet all day. She nods absently. He puts new plates on the table and serves red wine. He throws away the chipped glass and picks up the dirty dishes and brings them to the kitchen. He talks about his work, the foundation, a new donor, the next fundraiser. Evelyn focuses on the wine, red, just like… They finish their dinner, Evelyn walks through the hallway and notices a different framed picture, of her and Patrick at a charity gala. The reflection of a chandelier makes it look like a streak of red runs across their faces. She checks her phone and received a text from Catherine : Rest, don’t dwell on it. You did what you had to. Evelyn stares at it, trying to understand the meaning. She tries to scroll up with the conversation has been deleted. She types I keep thinking about her, but deletes it. She sends thank you instead.

She walks past the mirror at the end of the hall — her reflection seems to move half a second late. She looks into it. The hallway behind her flickers: once with her current self, once with the past — Vivienne’s shadow crossing it. The lights flicker softly as the sound of the clock grows louder again — the same ticking she heard in the interrogation room. Evelyn lies awake in bed beside Patrick, eyes open. His soft breathing contrasts with her restless mind.She stares at the ceiling, then turns toward the bedside clock: 2:37 AM. A faint reflection of red wine flashes across the clock face. The ticking continues — slow, steady, wrong.

Sunday Morning ? Monday Morning ? I don’t know

The bedside clock shows 2:59 AM, the reflection of red wine still pulses faintly on the clock. Evelyn lies awake, Patrick shifts beside her, restless. She hears a dripping sound, she thinks of wine, or blood, but it’s the bathroom tap. She hears movement downstairs, a faint clink, like a glass getting chipped. Her mind flickers to Vivienne’s apartment, the falling frame, the glass shattering. She rises quietly, trying to investigate the noise. She looks around the house, chasing a shadow. She calls for Patrick, once, but her voice sounds wrong and distant. She walks through the corridor, shadows long and cold. Every mirror surface catches her reflection half a beat behind. The clock reads 3:18 AM, but it hasn’t ticked forward since she left the bedroom. She sees a Post it note on a desk, she has to set the clock back to daylight savings time. When was that again ? She calls for Patrick again, but when he doesn’t answer she heads back to the bedroom.

She instead finds Patrick at the base of the stairs, one slipper halfway off, wine from the bottle he carried pooling near his head. A thin trickle of blood spreads beside it, but it’s indistinguishable in color. The composition mirrors her mental image of Vivienne’s death. She gasps and runs to her husband, slipping slightly on the liquid, smearing her hands. She tries to wake him up, but her voice cracks into sobs. For a moment, she sees Vivienne’s face beneath her hands. She blinks, it’s gone. The ticking returns, louder, arrhythmic. She stumbles to the phone and dials 911. Her description is confused. She mentions an apartment, wineglass. She says it was an accident. The dispatcher reminds her that no one has accused her yet. She kneels next to her husband caressing his face, smearing it in blood and wine, putting her prints all over his body. Lights flash against the manor wall. Catherine arrives, she doesn’t remember calling her. Evelyn tells him he fell, she didn’t touch him. Catherine nods, unsure if she believes her. We fade to the clock, 3:25 AM.

Evening

Royce and Pierce return with new photos and evidence. They mention finding a chipped glass in the trash, but it didn’t have any blood on it. They ask Evelyn to retell her version of events. She mentions Patrick was in the study, mentions the little blood she saw, which is inconsistent with the real scene) and recalls details that actually happened on Saturday, where Vivienne died, but she mixed up the days in her mind. Catherine starts to connect the dots herself, noting Evelyn’s memory gaps and emotional cues as Vivienne is mentioned. Royce and Pierce repeat the inconsistencies and Evelyn doubles down. Hints start to appear in evidence : gloves with foreign blood on it, a handbag that doesn’t belong to either Evelyn or Patrick, faint blood that doesn’t match Patrick’s. It makes them curious, but not accusatory yet. They retire from the interrogation room to confer with Luke to go over the evidence one more time. Catherine, who connected the dots, calms Evelyn down, saying we’ll sort this out together, she’s going to leave this place and go back in her room to get some much needed sleep.

Royce receives a call from Delorme, he puts him on speaker phone so Pierce and Morgan can hear it. He reminds him of the political pressure he’s under and to keep the investigation contained. He consults his colleagues and he points out they believe someone else might have been present at the manor.

Evelyn is left alone with Catherine, staring at her reflection: guilt, confusion, and the knowledge of Vivienne’s death, but the police haven’t connected the dots. Pierce tries calling Vivienne again, but it goes straight to voicemail. A police officer tells them the lady they’re trying to reach has been found dead in her apartment. Royce has a sudden look of realization, she didn’t lie, she just moved time.



HISTORY LESSON (SEASON 14)

 

Welcome to History Lesson, where we take a closer look at the movies that dare to tackle real-life events with varying levels of accuracy, drama, and WTF casting choices. These films promise to educate and entertain, but more often than not, they rewrite history with the subtlety of a sledgehammer. We’ll be your guide through the land of miscast biopics, dramatic embellishments, and historical “inspired-by” liberties, breaking down whether these flicks are Golden Reel Award-worthy masterpieces or just a big-budget Wikipedia summary. Either way, it’s more fun than your high school history class—and there’s popcorn.

This time around we will take a look at Season 14's fact-based slate....



HISTORY LESSON: THE YOUNG PRETENDER
The Young Pretender is a lavish, angst-filled chronicle of Charles Edward Stuart (Nicholas Hoult), aka Bonnie Prince Charlie, aka Scotland’s Biggest Mistake. With more wigs, swords, and melodrama than a season of The Crown, the film captures Charles’s quixotic attempt to reclaim the British throne for the Stuart family — because apparently, what the world needed was more monarchy. Hoult struts through the role with princely arrogance, while Anya Taylor-Joy plays Clementina, his lover who spends most of the runtime saying, “Maybe don’t do that,” only for Charles to, of course, do that.

While The Young Pretender nails the visuals (yes, Scotland looks majestic as ever), its grasp on history is shakier than a Highland charge. Charles’s ill-advised invasion of England is as entertainingly chaotic as it was in real life, though the film conveniently glosses over the fact that he was basically ghosted by the French when he begged for help. And yes, he really did flee Scotland disguised as a maid named Betty Burke — though it’s unclear if he nailed it as hard as Hoult does, complete with a sassy apron. The movie trades accuracy for spectacle, but honestly, watching Charles self-destruct while everyone around him rolls their eyes is its own kind of historical truth.




HISTORY LESSON: HARRELSON
David Mackenzie’s Harrelson dives headfirst into the outrageous and chaotic life of Charles Harrelson (Stephen Dorff), a man who transitioned from a charismatic hustler to a hitman with delusions of grandeur. The film opens with Harrelson confessing, during a cocaine-fueled standoff, to killing not just federal judge John Wood but also JFK — because why not? From there, we’re taken on a wild ride through his early cons, his questionable courtroom victories (thanks to David Strathairn’s oily defense attorney Percy Foreman), and his eventual unraveling as a coked-up outlaw whose biggest crime might just be oversharing.

The film's razor-sharp script finds humor in Harrelson’s blend of confidence and incompetence. From paying witnesses who conveniently vanish to leaving a murder trial thinking he’s untouchable, Dorff perfectly captures a man too reckless for his own schemes. Highlights include Giovanni Ribisi as sleazy gambler Pete Scamardo and Harrelson’s botched assassination plot against Judge Wood, which spirals into absurdity when he brags about it to an entire bar. Mackenzie masterfully balances the dark humor of Harrelson’s antics with the grim reality of his downfall, painting a portrait of a man too impulsive to realize he was his own worst enemy.




HISTORY LESSON: SUNNY DAYS
Sunny Days takes some liberties with historical accuracy, but hey, that’s showbiz. Did Tammy Sytch’s rise to fame include this much melodrama and scandal? Absolutely. Did every wrestler and promoter around her speak in perfectly scripted dialogue that conveniently moves the story forward? Probably not. The film tries to capture the chaos of the ‘90s wrestling scene, but at times it feels more like a TMZ reenactment than a true-to-life biography. And let’s not even talk about how sanitized the film handles Tammy’s later life struggles — she’s portrayed as messy but still redeemable, which is a bold choice considering the real-world headlines about her post-wrestling career.

Now, Jack Black as Tom Prichard? Inspired and hilariously off-the-wall. Sure, the real Prichard probably wasn’t cracking jokes like he’s in a School of Rock sequel, but Black brings a surprising amount of heart to the role. His chemistry with Lucas Till’s Chris Candido is one of the movie’s bright spots, even if it feels like they’re in an entirely different, far funnier movie. Meanwhile, Bradley Cooper as Vince McMahon continues to baffle — it’s as if they cast him hoping he’d charm audiences into forgetting that Vince is an intimidating, growly-voiced control freak. For a film set in the sweaty, chaotic world of professional wrestling, Sunny Days feels oddly polished, like a WrestleMania match that’s gone through one too many rewrites.




HISTORY LESSON: THE TEMPTATIONS
The Temptations struts onto the screen with sequins, soul, and just enough sanitized drama to make you wonder if Berry Gordy was peeking over Clint Eastwood’s shoulder the whole time. Credit where it’s due: this is a glossy, energetic tribute with killer music and an impressively committed ensemble—Corey Hawkins’ David Ruffin is appropriately magnetic and exhausting in equal measure, and Lakeith Stanfield’s Otis Williams makes stoicism feel (almost) cinematic. The musical numbers? Top-notch. The suits? Even better. But for all its smooth grooves, this Motown saga plays more like a well-rehearsed PR tour than a deep dive into one of music’s most volatile ensembles.

Historical accuracy takes a backseat to nostalgia here. Ruffin’s coke-fueled meltdowns and Paul’s tragic descent into alcoholism are present, but filtered through a PG-13 lens—like we’re watching the version you’d show in a high school music history class. The film keeps the timeline moving so fast it practically blurs major milestones (the group went through more lineup changes than the Avengers, but don’t expect too much clarity on who’s who after Act Two). And while the Motown politics are acknowledged, Berry Gordy’s depiction is suspiciously gentle—because of course the man who’s been mythologized for half a century comes off like a slightly irritable uncle instead of a calculating mogul. Still, despite the sanded edges and the faint scent of authorized biography, The Temptations is a toe-tapping, respectably reverent crowd-pleaser. Just don’t expect much more than what’s already in the liner notes.

Tuesday, June 23, 2026

PRESS X: METAL GEAR SOLID

 

I'm Alex Kirby and welcome to another outing of Press X. This time around we are moving on to the stealthy Metal Gear Solid. Here, we don’t just ask if the latest video game adaptation is faithful — we ask if it levels up, glitches out, or just needs a hard reset.




Many modern gamers may have only been introduced to Metal Gear Solid when it debuted on Playstation back in 1998, but it was actually the third game to a franchise that debuted a decade prior. Created by Hideo Kojima and developed by Konami, Metal Gear is one of the games that pioneered and popularized stealth and cinematic video games. Like my parents, Sega and Nintendo were too busy fighting with each other to notice the young child of Playstation growing up, becoming a formidable opponent in the Console War, and Metal Gear Solid was one of the weapons they had to keep their head above water in its infancy.

Now with a franchise across all platforms, the franchise is still alive and well, although new entries to the series has slowed down and all we see are ports and remakes. Fans hold debates over which Metal Gear Solid is the best, but most of us can all agree the first MGS is what made us fans.
Players control 'Solid Snake,' a soldier who infiltrates a nuclear weapons facility to neutralized a terrorist threat from FOXHOUND, a renegade special forces unit. Snake must free hostages and stop terrorists from launching a nuclear strike. The game's cinematic cutscenes were mind-blowing for the time, especially when you confront Psycho Mantis and he tells you(the Player) what other games you like to play by reading your memory card. I once thought my game was haunted when Psycho Mantis told me I played Castlevania: Symphony of the Night. Yep, needed a new controller after that night.

This is all why fans had been asking for a Metal Gear Solid movie. We wondered "Is Psycho Mantis going to tell us we saw The Avengers Endgame?" And in Season 3, we were going to find out. Written by Mark Newton and directed by Joseph Kosinski with Chris Evans as Snake, the film already had some big ambitions, much like the game of which it was based on.

The film plot itself, is basically the equivalent of the video game on the big screen, streamlined into a two-hour sci-fi action thrill-ride. A retired soldier, Solid Snake, is sent to infiltrate a remote Alaskan facility seized by the rogue FOXHOUND unit, who threaten nuclear annihilation using the walking tank Metal Gear REX. As he fights through deadly operatives and old allies turned enemies, Snake uncovers a conspiracy tying him to the project’s mastermind, the legacy of Big Boss, and a lethal virus hidden in his own body. What begins as a rescue mission becomes a battle for identity, survival, and the truth behind his creation.

While many fans may have liked it for its familiarity to the plot, making it less likely to ruin anything, the movie alienated fans who have already played the game and knew exactly what was going to happen.

Critics felt this sentiment, those who panned it said it did little more than give characters things to say and action scenes to perform. Critics who praised it loved Chris Evans' Solid Snake and Joseph Kosinski's direction.

For me personally, I'm happy we got a Metal Gear Solid film. It's narrative lends itself well to a movie adaptation, but I do think it relied too heavily on the game, hitting too many moments that happened in the game that made me think "I could have saved the price of admission and popped this into my Playstation and it wouldn't have been any different except for famous actors in the parts."

Despite my opinion, audiences still showed up in masses. A combined 428M with a heavy budget of 142M. It made 108M in profit. Clearly the studio took a gamble on it it, and it still paid off. It would go on to earn a Most Wanted Sequel nomination, and in a few seasons, we would certainly see Solid Snake again.
Since Metal Gear Solid, Mark Newton has become a career "big movie" writer, penning Marvel, Masters of the Universe and even Pompeii. Joseph Kosinski would be given director duties for the Batman franchise in LRF, and I can definitely see shades of a future Batman director when I watched Metal Gear Solid.

While Metal Gear Solid didn't try anything new with the franchise, it still came up as a winner. The cast and crew won, the studio won, even half of the fans won. The other half who wanted a fresh story? Not so much. 


RELEASE: 1016 WEST MONROE

 

1016 West Monroe
Genre: Drama/Musical
Director: Barry Jenkins
Writer: Meirad Tako
Cast: Quintessa Swindell, Lewis Pullman, Diana Silvers

Budget: $18,000,000
Domestic Box Office: $7,902,004
Foreign Box Office: $5,090,085
Total Profit: -$22,124,357

Reaction: This one just couldn't find an audience. Could it be the lack of star power? The genres? Or was it because Google directed everyone looking for a showing to a Chicago condominium? 



"This is a highly ambitious, atmospheric film that nails the jazz-soaked grit of 1950s Chicago. Its distinct style is refreshing, the music is ever-present, and the film clearly understands the culture it’s romanticizing. Where it stumbles is in its supporting characters: Bianca’s villainy escalates a little too quickly, while Lawrence feels underdeveloped for how central he’s meant to be. Barbara remains an engaging lead, though her character is loaded with so much symbolism that she occasionally feels more thematic than human. Still, it’s a well-made musical that actually likes music, and honestly, that alone earns it points." - Tim Durand, San Francisco Chronicle


"1016 West Monroe is a soulful, lyrical character piece that unfolds like a jazz composition—fluid, intimate, and emotionally resonant. Barry Jenkins directs with patience and precision, while Quintessa Swindell delivers a magnetic performance that carries the film’s quiet intensity. It’s a story of ambition and sacrifice that lingers well beyond its final note." - George Ryan, Philadelphia Inquirer 



"Despite its visual polish, 1016 West Monroe struggles to translate style into compelling drama. The film drifts through loosely connected moments, with conflicts that feel underdeveloped and repetitive. Quintessa Swindell, while occasionally effective, lacks the commanding presence needed to anchor a film this dependent on its lead, leaving key emotional beats feeling distant rather than immersive. Diana Silvers fares better, bringing sharper definition to Bianca, but the story around them feels meandering and self-indulgent. It’s a film that wants to feel like jazz, but too often just wanders off-tempo." - Dave Manning, Ridgefield Press






Rated R for language, some sexual content, and thematic material.