The Hammer of Thor: The Frost War - Writer Commentary
Genre: Action/Superhero/Fantasy
Director: Roar Uthaug
Writer: Roy Horne
Based on Marvel Comics characters
Cast: Channing Tatum, Sam Riley, Phoebe Dynevor, Mark Hamill, Sophie Lowe, Laurie Davidson, Denis Menochet, Sung Kang, Jeanne Tripplehorn, Caitriona Balfe, Thomas Ian Griffith
Plot: Thor (Channing Tatum) reigns as a legendary Viking king in the village of Heorot. While the people still sing songs of his might and raise cups of mead in his honor, Thor feels the ache of time. The thrill of battle and glory has dulled, and his thoughts drift increasingly toward Johanna—the love he lost. One quiet night beneath the stars, he travels to Asgard and asks Odin (Mark Hamill) for permission to enter the Odinsleep, hoping to be awakened when her soul returns to Midgard. Odin agrees, though with reluctance, and seals Thor in the golden chamber, whispering that the thunder god’s time will come again. [1]
[1] Welcome back for Thor's second film in LRF's Marvel Universe. While a lot of what I had planned in this second film was planned from the beginning, I'm the few critics who had qualms with my choices in The Hammer of Thor thought they had an impact on the story for this one. Sorry to disappoint.
This opening scene was all about subverting expectations. At the end of the first film, Thor has become everything he thought he wanted to be. He's worthy, he's a hero, he's beloved by his people. But grief doesn't really work that way. Losing Johanna still hurts. One thing I knew pretty early was that I didn't want Thor spending centuries simply waiting around for her return. The Odinsleep felt like a very Thor way to solve that problem, and it also let us flip the traditional Marvel dynamic where Odin is usually the one entering it. More than anything, though, I liked the idea that Thor's journey to become worthy was finished, but his journey to find happiness wasn't.
Centuries later, in the icy realm of Jotunheim, King Laufey (Thomas Ian Griffith) gathers his frost generals in a glacial fortress. He informs them that Odin’s power wanes and now is the time to strike. But to truly seize Asgard, Laufey knows he must sow chaos from within. A swirl of green mist signals the arrival of Amora (Caitriona Balfe) the Enchantress. She proposes a deeper alliance, promising to use her seidr to unlock the seals binding Loki within Yggdrasill itself. In exchange, Laufey must lend his armies and magic to her cause. They clasp hands, sealing the pact. [2]
[2] One thing I wanted to establish immediately was that this wasn't another story about Thor proving himself. That journey ended in the first film. The Frost War is much more about kingdoms, alliances, and old enemies taking advantage of weakness. That's why Laufey appears so early. I didn't want him to be a surprise. I wanted him looming over the entire movie. I also knew this was the scene where Amora needed to step out of Loki's shadow a little. In the first film she was mostly enabling Loki's worst impulses. Here she's the one bringing the plan to the table. The audience starts realizing she's every bit as dangerous as he is. Another interesting aspect I was going for with this scene is that Laufey thinks he's using Amora, and Amora thinks she's using Laufey.
In the golden city, Odin’s steps are slower, his breath heavier. Frigga senses his time nearing. Odin clutches Gungnir tighter, knowing his final days approach. Sensing Laufey’s first waves, Odin leads Lady Sif (Sophie Lowe) and the Warriors Three - Fandral (Laurie Davidson) the Dashing, Volstagg (Denis Menochet) the Valiant, and Hogun (Sung Kang) the Grim - into battle against advancing frost scouts near the cliffs of Vanaheim's border. Frost giants lumber from the mists, hurling spears of ice into the Asgardian lines. Volstagg barrels through the front ranks, swinging his axe, cleaving frost giant limbs that shatter upon impact. Hogun uses a grappling chain to topple a frost behemoth into a crevasse. Fandral sprints ahead, leaping onto a frost giant’s shoulder and driving his blade through its eye, riding the collapsing corpse down. Sif cuts down frost giants trying to breach the line. She ducks under a hammer swing and slashes through a giant’s leg, then impales its throat as it falls. [3]
[3] One thing I wanted to do in the sequel was give Sif and the Warriors Three a chance to really shine. The first film is very much Thor's story, but once we committed to making this a war movie, it felt important to show why these characters have become legends in their own right. Everybody gets a moment that reflects who they are—Volstagg through strength, Hogun through discipline, Fandral through style, and Sif through sheer skill. The battle itself is fun, but the most important thing happening in the scene is actually Odin. For the first time, he's slowing down. He's still leading from the front, but age is finally catching up to him, and the audience starts realizing that Asgard may soon have to face this war without its king.
In the icy citadel of Jotunheim, King Laufey convenes his frost generals amid a chorus of clashing weapons and stomping feet. Amora emerges from a plume of green mist, her presence drawing a mixture of reverence and suspicion. One particularly defiant general steps forward, voicing doubt about Laufey’s reliance on seidr and accusing him of cowardice. Laufey answers not with words, but with swift execution, summoning a jagged spear of ice that impales the giant, leaving him encased in frozen death. The remaining generals fall silent. Laufey states that this war will be fought with magic, not brute strength, and with Amora by his side, they will bring a new age of winter upon the realms. [4]
[4] This scene was really about establishing Laufey as more than just Loki's father. I wanted him to feel like a legitimate rival to Odin—a king who's spent centuries waiting for an opportunity and isn't interested in letting tradition stand in his way. That's why he executes the general. The giant isn't completely wrong. Frost Giants usually solve problems with strength. Laufey is deliberately choosing a different path.
Meanwhile, far beneath the heart of the city, Amora creeps through the roots of Yggdrasill, where a shimmering veil of magic holds Loki captive. She draws an ancient, enchanted blade, and plunges it into a knot in the Yggdrasill. The roots twist and groan. A pulse of green energy bursts outward as Loki collapses forward. Loki is hurled into a mental abyss of memory and illusion — Odin glaring in disappointment and Frigga turning away with sorrow in her eyes. The tree releases its hold, and Loki awakens on the ground. He rises slowly, brushing sap from his tunic. Loki tells Amora that he never intends on being caged ever again. [5]
[5] This scene was never really about breaking Loki out of prison. Everybody knows he's getting out. The interesting part is what centuries inside Yggdrasill have done to him. I liked the idea that his punishment wasn't physical so much as emotional. He's forced to relive the moments that shaped him—Balder's death, Odin's disappointment, Frigga's sorrow. One thing that's always fascinated me about Loki is that he spends so much time acting like he doesn't care what his family thinks, when in reality he cares more than anyone.
Loki does not go straight to the battle. Instead, he slips away into the realm of the frost giants. In Jotunheim, he confronts Laufey, demanding the truth. Laufey reveals the secret of Loki’s bloodline — that he is Laufey’s son, abandoned and left for dead by Odin, who raised him as an Asgardian only to cast him aside. The revelation stirs something deep and cold within Loki. Laufey tells him that he can choose where he truly belongs. Loki does not hesitate, deciding to join Laufey and Amora in the fight against Asgard. [6]
[6] This is one of those scenes where I wasn't trying to surprise anybody. Most Thor fans know the frost giant reveal is eventually coming. What interested me was the timing. In a lot of versions, Loki discovers the truth before he falls. Here he learns it after everything has already gone wrong. He's spent centuries imprisoned, replaying his mistakes, feeling abandoned by his family, and then Laufey shows up with the one explanation he's always wanted to hear.
Odin storms forward atop a silver war-steed, blasting enemies with Gungnir. He dismounts and meets Laufey in a clearing surrounded by broken statues and burning trees. Laufey, powered by Amora's enchantments, drives a shard of ice into Odin's side. Odin, weakened from Laufey's strike, turns to see Loki approaching. Loki whispers something in Odin's ear, then plunges a dagger directly into Odin's heart. Odin gasps, then crumples to the ground. The battle continues to rage, now around Odin's fallen body. [7]
[7] I knew from the beginning that if Odin died, it couldn't just be another battle casualty. The Frost War is the backdrop, but the real story is still this family. That's why Laufey doesn't get the killing blow. Loki does. In a lot of ways, this moment has been building since the opening scenes of the first movie. Odin spends years trying to protect Asgard, but the thing he never quite figures out is his own son. One detail I always loved was the whisper before the stab. We never tell the audience what Loki says because I think the mystery is more interesting than the answer. For me, Odin isn't really killed by Laufey or even by Loki. He's killed by the consequences of mistakes that have been following this family for generations.
Frigga senses the loss of her husband in her heart. She enters the Odinsleep chamber and awakens Thor. As his eyes open, she tells him that Odin has been slain by Laufey and Loki, and that the frost giants have returned to Jotunheim for now. Amora has vanished - and Asgard mourns. Thor descends upon the battlefield where Odin fell. His father's spear lies shattered. Thor’s knuckles tighten around Mjolnir. The Warriors Three and Lady Sif approach to offer their condolences. Frigga joins her son to mourn the God of Wisdom. She tells her son that he must decide what truly matters to him. Not out of obligation to a throne or a legacy — but from his own heart. Thor nods and says that he must go to Midgard. Frigga lets him go, saying he will find his answer there.
Jane Foster moves through her busy life as a London nurse. At night, Jane wakes in a cold sweat in her London flat, her heart pounding from a vivid dream. She walks to her window to see storm clouds forming unnaturally in the sky. Drawn by an urge she doesn’t understand, she picks up her sketchbook and begins to draw—first the ruins of a village, then a monument bearing her own face beside a man in armor. As she flips through earlier pages, she sees images of the Bifrost, a sea serpent, and a golden city she’s never seen. When a bolt of otherworldly lightning crashes into a remote part of the city, Jane finds herself drawn to the crater — where a figure in armor slowly rises from the smoke - Thor. He follows her through the city, insisting she is someone he once loved. She resists, dismissing him as a lunatic. But when he describes places and memories from dreams she never told anyone about, her skepticism falters. He asks her to come with him to Denmark — to the ruins of a village named Heorot. There, Jane sees a monument - one that bears her own likeness beside Thor's. Her memories begin to stir. Thor tells her the truth: that she is the reincarnation of Johanna, and that fate has brought them together again. [8]
[8] This was probably the scene I was most nervous about because so much of the movie depends on it. The audience has to believe that Jane isn't simply somebody who looks like Johanna. She has to feel like Johanna. That's why the dreams, the sketches, and the memories all start showing up before Thor ever explains anything
Lady Sif finds Thor and Jane in London. Just as she arrives, frost giants descend upon the city, targeting Thor before he can return to Asgard. Thor channels a burst of lightning that levels the pavement and the giants themselves, confirming everything Jane feared — and hoped — was true. She watches in awe as he becomes the god she’s seen in dreams. Sif warns Thor that Asgard has been gripped in an unnatural winter since his departure. The skies have remained overcast, the ground frozen solid, and the frost giants’ magic lingers everywhere. She tells him Loki and Amora are surely behind it, working with Laufey to poison the realm. Sif pleads with him to return home, insisting that Asgard needs him more than ever. Thor glances at Jane, torn between his destiny and his heart. Jane, sensing the weight of his conflict, steps forward and says she’s coming with him. Thor and Jane step into the Bifrost with Sif, bound for the golden realm. [9]
[9] This is really the scene where all the separate storylines finally collide. We'd spent the first act with Odin, Loki, Laufey, Jane, and Thor all moving in different directions. Now they're finally headed toward the same destination. One thing I especially liked was making sure Jane chose to go to Asgard. The easy version is Thor asking her to come. The stronger version is Jane deciding for herself. That's the moment she really starts becoming the same kind of person Johanna was. I also liked letting her finally see Thor as the God of Thunder. Up until now she's only known him through dreams and stories. For the first time she gets to see the legend with her own eyes.
When they arrive back in Asgard, they find the golden city under an invasion. Great ice pillars have formed across the Rainbow Bridge while Laufey stands at the heart of the invasion, commanding frost giants. Thor, Jane, and Sif step off the Bifrost and quickly rendezvous with the Warriors Three near the shattered gates. [10] The reunion is brief — Fandral grins but nods solemnly toward the battle, while Volstagg clasps Thor’s arm in welcome. Hogun wastes no time updating them on the state of the defenses. Seeing the danger all around them, Thor turns to Jane. He tells her she must stay safe and asks her to go with his mother. Jane hesitates, but Frigga emerges from the shadows, reassuring her. Frigga takes Jane’s hand, and the two disappear into the golden corridors as Thor, Sif, and the Warriors Three charge toward the fray.
[10] I always loved those classic Kirby splash pages where Thor arrives and immediately reunites with his friends in the middle of a battle. If Asgard is losing a war, nobody has time for a reunion scene. This is close as it gets. I also wanted to make sure that Jane's first proper visit to Asgard isn't a tour - it's a literal disaster.
Fandral leads a squad of cavalry atop winged beasts. At one point, he leaps from his saddle onto a towering ice golem and slashes its core, bringing it crashing down. Volstagg holds a shattered gate alone, swinging his massive axe through wave after wave of giants. Meanwhile, Sif and Hogun track Amora to the deep forest of Vanaheim. Sif challenges Amora directly. Amora conjures illusions that attack Sif. Hogun fends off the conjurings, allowing Sif to push toward Amora, who blasts magic at Sif, who barely is able to defend herself with a shield. Sif swings her sword - not at Amora, but at Amora's staff, shattering it into pieces. Amora panics. Sif then punches her in the face, knocking her out cold. [11]
[11] This scene was really about giving Sif her moment. Across both films she's usually the most competent person in the room, but she's rarely the center of the story. I knew eventually she needed a victory that belonged entirely to her. One thing I liked was that she doesn't beat Amora by overpowering her. Amora is probably the more powerful character in a raw magical sense. Sif wins because she figures out where that power is coming from and takes it away. That's very different from how Thor approaches problems. It's also probably the most comic-booky thing Sif does in either movie. And after all the magic and illusions, I always enjoyed ending the fight with a punch. Sometimes the simplest solution is still the most satisfying one.
Thor ascends the steps of Valaskjalf to confront Laufey, who conjures ice chains, binding Thor to the mountain. Laufey taunts Thor, claiming that Thor cannot begin to comprehend his plan for the future of Asgard. Loki emerges, confronting Laufey, demanding to know if this was ever meant to be a shared rule as Laufey had alluded. Laufey scoffs, telling him that he was never more than a discarded heir, a means to an end. Angered, Loki declares that he’s done with fathers and vanishes in a swirl of emerald flame. [12] Thor breaks free and launches Mjolnir into the heavens. The hammer, supercharged with lightning, crashes into Laufey and shatters him into a thousand frozen shards.
[12] The irony is that Loki spends centuries convinced Odin never truly wanted him, only to discover Laufey wants him even less. While I was tempted to follow the traditional path of a big, epic battle between Thor and Laufey, it honestly seemed to obvious. The big moment was already with Loki rejecting Laufey, so I felt that arc was complete without further spectacle. Plus, we're obviously not quite done yet as I always thought that Laufey worked best as the man who opened the door, not the thing that came through it.
Before the dust can settle, the ground begins to tremble. Frigga realizes that Laufey's death was a catalyst - a sacrifice to summon the Father of All Frost, Ymir. From the chasm of Ginnungagap, a towering being of glacier emerges. Ymir rises from the void, dwarfing the mountains of Asgard. He speaks in ancient tongues, roaring as he steps onto the edge of Asgard. With each movement, he reshapes the realm in ice. Loki, never made aware of the summoning of Ymir, decides to leave the side of Amora and frost giants. [13]
[13] Laufey was important, but once I decided I wanted include Ymir, I knew Laufey could not be the final obstacle. The first movie builds toward Jormungandr. The second builds toward Ymir. I wanted to pull from new layers in Norse mythology for each entry. And for the first time in the entire series, Loki isn't involved or behind what's happening.
Thor realizes he cannot defeat Ymir alone. He calls for the heroes to regroup. Volstagg rallies wounded Asgardian warriors to hold the gates. Fandral mounts one final flight with the last of the Valkyrian steeds to distract the behemoth from above. Sif and Hogun return with the unconscious Amora. Sif turns to Frigga, asking for ancient seidr to weaken Ymir’s core. Frigga agrees but needs time to complete the spell. As the chaos of Ymir’s emergence escalates, Loki suddenly appears among the defenders. Thor levels Mjolnir at him, demanding to know why he has returned. Loki simply states that the ice he thought he belonged to now threatens all nine realms, not just Asgard. Thor hesitates. Sif and Volstagg urge caution. But Frigga steps forward and speaks to Loki — not as a queen, but as a mother. She asks both of her sons what Balder would have done. Thor lowers Mjolnir. Loki nods, smirking faintly, and says they’ll settle things after. For now, they will fight side by side. [14]
[14] The Thor from the first film absolutely attacks Loki here. Odin spent two movies trying to hold the family together as a king, but I felt Frigga should have the opposite parenting approach and manages to unite those left not as a queen but as a mother. Loki may be choosing to help his family, but he's definitely not a hero - he's still the same person he was before just with a slightly different allegiance.
Thor and Loki soar through the skies, combining thunder and illusion magic to blind Ymir. Frigga opens a golden seidr beam into Ymir’s heart — revealing a crystalline core pulsing with ancient cold. Thor rises high into the sky, calling down the largest storm Asgard has ever known. With one final burst, he hurls himself straight into Ymir’s heart. Mjolnir follows, wrapped in thunder and Loki's magic. The blast shatters the core. Ymir screams once, then collapses into an avalanche of ice. Loki vanishes before anyone can thank — or arrest — him. A folded note is pinned to Gungnir. It reads only: “I kept my word. For now.” [15]
[15] I never wanted Thor to beat Ymir alone. One thing I knew from very early on was that this story couldn't end with Thor defeating Loki or Loki defeating Thor. It had to end with them accomplishing something together. Across two movies they're constantly pulling in opposite directions, but Ymir is finally a threat big enough that neither one can solve the problem alone. That's why I liked combining Thor's lightning, Loki's magic, and Frigga's seidr into the final solution. It's really the entire family contributing to the victory. The other thing I always felt strongly about was Loki leaving afterward. The easy version is reconciliation. And anyone who knows my writing knows I rarely choose the easy way out for the characters.
Deep beneath the golden palace, Frigga and Sif descend into the hollowed heart of the World Tree. Amora is bound in glowing chains of siedr. With a word, Frigga awakens the roots of the tree, which wrap around Amora, cocooning her. [16]
[16] One thing I didn't realize as I was writing the project was that while the first film clearly belonged to Thor, this sequel quietly belongs to Frigga.
The people of Asgard finally have a moment to properly mourn Odin and hold a grand funeral. Frigga passes Gungnir to Thor. The other gods kneel before Thor. Frigga tells Jane that she may have been Johanna once, she has the chance now to shape her own story. Thor meets Jane at the Bifrost. She tells him that she intends to return to Earth as it is her home. Thor understands. Before she leaves, Jane asks about the woman Thor once loved. He describes Johanna as beautiful and the only soul that ever made him question himself. He then says that he gets the same feeling when he's around Jane. They lean into each other and kiss goodbye - for now.
Back in Midgard, Jane visits the ruins of Heorot. She looks up to the skies. Somewhere beyond the clouds, she knows thunder rolls. Meanwhile in Asgard, Thor takes Odin's place at the throne. All the residents of Asgard kneel before Thor, their new king. [17]
[17] The idea of this ending was to bring Thor back to where he was in the first scene of the first film, but now on the throne himself rather than looking up at his father alongside his brothers.
Post-Credits Scene:
Deep within Muspelheim, a massive horned figure opens its eyes - Surtr. He watches the void left behind by Ymir’s fall and begins forging a massive molten sword. [18]
[18] Obviously this is the set up for the third Hammer of Thor film, which is still very much in development. This is probably the least subtle thing I've ever written.
Thanks again for listening to my ramblings. See you next time at the movies.
No comments:
Post a Comment